Buster’s Sports Tavern

Reviews

• Rob P.

  star star star star star_border 10 June 2026

  Great value, homemade and fresh, not frozen bar food, better than your average sports bar.
  
  I've been wanting to try this place for years as it's on the way home from the boat ramp/marina, casual enough after a day on the water, and advertised specials seemed like great deals. We tried it today and I'm glad we did.
  
  Clean atmosphere, pool tables and other games, spacious with inside and outside fast seating.  Special was 1 lb.. sirloin with baked potato, house salad, and veg - 11.95.  I thought for sure the steak would below par at that price but, a deal anyway... the steak was great, big, tender, lean, and surprisingly juicy. Also tried fried pickles and jumbo wings. Everything seemed fresh and homemade, service was good, decent beer selection, and fantastic prices and portions.
  
  4 people with beers (different, cheaper draft specials are available) solft drinks, shrimp basket and fried pickle apps, and 4 entrees - 80 bucks with leftovers.  Will definitely go again.  After a day on the water in Sanibel, great place to dip in for a quick, real food, casual meal.... the kind of place you could eat at 2 to 3 times a week, have something different each time, and not break the bank.

• Ally C.

  star star star star star_border 7 June 2026

  Typical local sports bar but you can't beat the Monday Pizza Special. Their pizza is one of the best in the area that I've tried so far and for 1/2 price large pizzas on money you can't pass it up!

• John S.

  star star star star star_border 28 May 2026

  Last night after a short Uber drive the six of us rolled into this place at 11 pm when unable to find anything open close to our hotel.  Tired and hungry from a long day of travel and not knowing what to expect we ordered wings and pizza based on a recommendation from a bar patron and it was top notch.  If we ever get back to Ft Meyers we will come back and try something else on the menu.

• Amber H.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  There's not much to say about this place, so I'll keep it short and sweet. It's a run of the mill sports bar. The place was dead when we walked in, yet every booth was dirty. We ordered all you can eat shrimp, the "daily special ", but only got to have one round, because the server never checked on us. Yet, she checked on her other tables multiple times. The food was great, but I won't be back, due to the service and lack of cleanliness.

• Julie D.

  star star star star star_border 16 May 2026

  My daughters and I stopped in for a beer around 2:00pm.  The bar was full and was a really fun crowd. We came back for dinner that night.
  
  Can't beat the $11.99 lb sirloin. A lot of food!  You will not leave hungry.
  
  You must try the mozzarella cheese sticks.  Amazing!!  In the past I also had the open face turkey. Perfect comfort food!  
  
  Beers are on ice!  Be sure to ask to play the $1 dice game. My go to place when we come to town.